Women who drink eight or
more cups of coffee a day during preg-nancy could be doubling
or even trebling the risk of losing their child compared
to those who abstain, say researchers. Even four cups a day,
regarded as a safe level, could increase the chance of stillbirth
by as much as 80%, they say.
The research findings published today confirm an earlier anecdotal
link between high doses of caffeine and baby death and evidence
from studies involving monkeys but the results could also increase
anxiety among pregnant women about the safety of common foods
and drinks after they were told on Monday to avoid eating too
much tuna.
Kirsten Wisborg, a specialist registrar at the Aarhus University
Hospital in Denmark who led the study, said, "The risk
of stillbirth increased with the number of cups of coffee
a day during pregnancy.
"Compared to women who did not drink any coffee, women
who drank four to seven cups had an 80% increased risk of
stillbirth and women who drank eight or more cups a day a
300% increased
risk."
The Danish study, which is published in the British Medical
Journal, focused on more than 18,000 pregnant women and found
that heavy coffee drinkers were also more likely to smoke,
drink more alcohol, be single parents and have less education.
Even after adjusting for the effect of smoking during pregnancy,
the association between coffee consumption and stillbirth was
just as significant.
"The adjusted risk of stillbirth was lower among women
who drank one to three cups per day, slightly increased among
women who
drank four to seven cups a day and more than doubled among
women who drank eight or more cups of coffee per day," said
the research team.
"These results seem to indicate a threshold effect
around four to seven cups a day.
"There did not seem to be one single cause that could
explain the increased risk of stillbirth among women with
a high intake
of coffee."
This latest warning of a risk to the health of unborn babies
comes just days after pregnant women were warned to limit the
amount of tuna they eat because of the small risk that mercury
in the fish posed to unborn and breastfeeding babies' developing
nervous systems.
Pregnant women have also been advised to avoid eating shark,
swordfish and marlin.
The Food Standards Agency has been advising pregnant women
to limit their caffeine intake to less than 300mg, four cups
of coffee, a day, for the past two years after the Committee
on Toxicity of Chemicals in Food, Consumer Products and the
Environment linked it to low birth weight and miscarriage.
A limit of 300mg is the equivalent to six cups of tea, eight
cans of regular cola drinks, four cans of caffeine-based energy
drinks or eight 40g bars of chocolate.
A spokeswoman for the Food Standards Agency said, "Although
we have just seen the paper, its findings seem to be broadly
consistent with the body of evidence on the effects of caffeine
on pregnant women which was reviewed by the Committee on
Toxicity and led the FSA to advise pregnant women to limit
their caffeine
intake to 300mg or four cups of coffee a day.
"Unless a more extensive look at the research shows
something different there doesn't seem to be any need to
review our position."
A dietitian at the University Hospital of Wales in Cardiff,
Jacqui Lowdon, said she and her colleagues would not be making
any changes to their recommendations based on advice from the
Royal College of Midwives and the Centre for Preg-nancy Nutrition,
for a daily caffeine intake of not more than 300mg, as a result
of the Danish study.
British Coffee Association spokesman Roger Cook said pregnant
women should not be alarmed by the results of the latest study.
"The results of this study do not alter the advice
given to pregnant women on caffeine consumption during pregnancy
by
the Food Standards Agency which states that 300mg caffeine,
equivalent to three mugs or four cups of coffee per day,
is perfectly safe and will have no adverse effect on the mother
or the foetus," he said.
"Further, the Centre for Pregnancy Nutrition states
that it is perfectly safe for a pregnant woman to drink up
to four
or five cups of coffee or tea a day while pregnant or breastfeeding."
Madeleine
Brindley Madeleine.Brindley@Wme.Co.Uk, The Western Mail - The
National Newspaper Of Wales, Feb. 21, 2003